This holiday season, Rudolph won’t be the only reindeer fighting for respect. In CHARMZ: The Other Reindeer, a new musical from Nygel D. Robinson (music and lyrics) and Ken-Matt Martin (book), in its world premiere at Baltimore Center Stage Nov. 13-Dec. 27, a young, musically inclined reindeer at a Motown-styled North Pole desperately wants to go on a “world tour” with Santa.
The new show was born when BCS, looking for their own holiday perennial à la A Christmas Carol, first explored licensable titles like Elf and The Grinch. But when Martin, BCS’s executive director, and artistic director Stevie-Walker Webb considered the multi-year licensing costs and tricky logistics of such titles, they opted instead to commission an original musical from Robinson (a Mexodus co-writer). To hear Martin and Robinson tell it, mere hours passed between their first phone call and Robinson’s first song for the show.
Going beyond the classic Rudolph story, they imagined a Baltimore-specific reindeer, Charmz (after Baltimore’s “Charm City” nickname), who hopes to one day shine as brightly as the red-nosed legend. Unlike Rudolph, whose nose showed the way for Santa’s sleigh, Charmz’s power is in his music.
“What we ultimately landed on was, we want this reindeer to speak to Black children, specifically in Baltimore,” Robinson said, “and to be like: You don’t have to have that red nose like Rudolph to be special. You don’t have to be able to fly to be special. You can just be special all by yourself.”
Robinson infused Martin’s book with a Motown-inspired original score. Though they’re not parody songs or send-ups, Robinson and Martin did toss around deep-cut soul tunes from the era alongside beloved hits as they searched for the right feel in certain key moments.
“That’s what we grew up on,” Martin said. “Nygel and I are both old souls and old spirits, and also grew up in the South, where I think the proliferation of that music feels more present in a lot of ways in your everyday households.”
This Motown inspiration extends to the characters. Santa is a take on the label founder Berry Gordy. And the core reindeer comprise five Yuletidettes (The Temptations) and three Mistletoes (The Supremes), as well as Charmz, whom Martin described as a mix of Stevie Wonder and young Michael Jackson—i.e., a prodigy. There’s even an elf take on Motown manager Shelly Berger.
At the very least, that opportunity has given CHARMZ an annual stage in Baltimore for the foreseeable future. Martin, though, hopes that the show resonates with folks beyond Baltimore as they hear through the grapevine about a new holiday fixture.
“It is going to be what A Christmas Carol is for the next generation,” Walker-Webb said. “We’re tired of the same old holiday shows. This one really centers Motown music and Black culture in a really beautiful way.”
And it’s not the only show of its kind on BCS stages, Martin pointed out.
“I’m very proud to say that we have two musicals premiere in this season, both from writers of color, that are helping to further expand the musical theatre canon,” Martin said, referring to the May 2027 premiere of XTRAVAGANZA, with a book by R. Eric Thomas and music and lyrics by Khiyon Hursey. “That’s not by accident; that’s intentional. We’re being unapologetic about saying we want to create more opportunities for composers of color to be able to come and know that this is a place they can tell stories.”
Jerald Raymond Pierce is managing editor of American Theatre.
Support American Theatre: a just and thriving theatre ecology begins with information for all. Please join us in this mission by joining TCG, which entitles you to copies of our quarterly print magazine and helps support a long legacy of quality nonprofit arts journalism.



